The Corps has an administrative appeal process whereby applicants and landowners may appeal denied permits, issued permits that contain requirements that are unacceptable to the applicant or jurisdictional determinations, which are made by the Alaska District. The request for an appeal of such decisions must be submitted to the Corps within 60 days of the date of the appealable decision. A site visit or an appeal conference or meeting may be conducted during the appeal process.
The Pacific Ocean Division located in Hawaii is responsible for making appeal decisions for the Alaska District. The POD office normally makes a decision on the merits of the appeal based on the administrative record in 90 days. The division will either uphold the district decision or remand the case back to the district with direction for reconsideration of the district’s initial determination. After re-evaluation, the district is to make a final decision. This final decision is not subject to further appeal.
The level of evaluation is on par with the level of the environmental impacts, aquatic functions and values involved in a particular area. Impacts to higher ecological value areas will be subject to a more detailed evaluation and a strong focus on avoidance of impacts to the aquatic environment.
The status and disposition of appeals in the Alaska District is shown below:
Applicant & Location |
Processing Number
|
Type of Appeal |
Date Received |
Date Completed |
Appeal Decision |
Final District Action |
Travis/Peterson Environmental Consulting, Inc., on behalf of Mick Killion |
POA-1991-673-9 |
Jurisdictional |
9/8/08 |
11/13/09 |
Remanded |
JD being revised |
Talbot, Inc. |
POA-2006-888-M |
Permit Denial |
4/3/08 |
7/18/08 |
Denial determined to be a supportable decision, but District instructed to review permits for adjacent structures |
|
TERRASAT, Inc. |
POA-2006-1282-4 |
Jurisdictional |
1/25/08 |
3/14/08 |
Determined not eligible for appeal |
No action required |
Travis/Peterson Environmental Consulting, Inc., on behalf of Great Northwest, Inc., Fairbanks |
POA-1994-143-9 |
Jurisdictional |
1/21/08 |
7/28/08 |
Partially Remanded |
JD revised and reissued asserting jurisdiction |
Fairbanks North Star Borough, Fairbanks |
POA-2005-1845-9 |
Jurisdictional |
2/8/06 |
5/26/06 |
No Merit |
No Action Required |
Swan Bay-Anchorage |
POA-1984-184-Z |
Permit Denial |
11/20/03 |
10/5/04 |
Merit |
|
Carr-Gottstein - Anchorage |
POA-1996-88 |
Jurisdictional |
9/5/03 |
4/5/04 |
Merit |
|
Lawrence Albert - Anchorage |
POA-1985-486-9 |
Jurisdictional |
6/12/03 |
Postponed at applicant request until Jan 04 |
|
|
Head Property - Craig, Alaska |
POA-2001-0477-2 |
Permit Denial |
2/12/03 |
7/14/03 |
No Merit |
No Action Required |
Persinger/HutchinsonFairbanks, Alaska |
POA-2002-0236-4 |
Permit Denial |
1/10/03 |
6/19/03 |
No Merit |
No Action Required |
William Thompson Fairbanks, Alaska |
POA-2002-618-4 |
Jurisdictional |
7/8/02 |
12/13/02 |
No Merit |
No Action Required |